Islington Council has agreed to pay £48.6 million to settle the final building bills for two of its estate housing schemes. The contractor had put in a final claim at what the council calls “a significantly higher figure”.

The two schemes are the Elthorne Estate in N19 and the Park View Estate in N5. The settlement splits as:

  • Elthorne Estate: £26.6 million
  • Park View Estate: £22.0 million

The council’s Corporate Director of Community Wealth Building, Stephen Biggs, approved the settlement on 20 October. The decision notice was published on 11 November.

Why the bill was disputed

The notice says the builder’s final claim was well above the figures certified by the council’s own external cost consultants. It does not say how much was claimed.

The council says “sustained challenge and negotiation” brought the figure down to £48.6 million. It describes that as a fair settlement given “complex programme delays and wider industry challenges”.

It considered two alternatives and rejected both:

  • Formal dispute routes such as adjudication. The notice says this carried “significant risk” because of the uncertain outcome, and would need substantial council resources.
  • More negotiation. The council says it had already won a reduction and saw the settlement as fair.

The notice does not give the original contract price, so it is not possible to say from it how far the final cost moved.

What the money paid for

The council’s new-build page describes both schemes. Both started in early 2021.

Elthorne Estate, N19 Park View Estate, N5
Work started February 2021 January 2021
New homes 46 31
Mix 16 council, 22 for sale, 8 shared ownership all council homes
Other work estate roads, public spaces, play areas, a games court at Zoffany Park a community space, landscaping
Final account £26.6m £22.0m

At Elthorne the homes are on the sunken sports pitch and the old St John’s community centre site. The page gave an expected finish of January 2026. At Park View it said 20 of the 31 homes were finished and occupied.

A smaller settlement on Windsor Street

On the same day, Mr Biggs also settled the final account for Rosehip House on Windsor Street, N1. The council’s page describes it as 11 council homes of supported housing for people with learning disabilities, with support on site around the clock.

The Rosehip House notice records:

  • a final account of £6.85 million
  • £197,306 still to pay
  • a £74,000 shortfall on the scheme budget, covered by money left over from the Telfer House scheme on Lever Street

The council’s own surveyors judged that sum to be what the contractor was owed under the contract.

What it means for you

  • The two estate bills are now closed at £48.6 million. The council chose to settle rather than risk a formal dispute with an uncertain outcome.
  • The notices do not say which budget covers the cost, or whether it affects rents or service charges. Neither is a key decision, so neither went to the Executive.
  • The amount the builder originally claimed has not been published.