Islington Council wants to turn the Tompion Community Hall on Percival Street into an office for its parking team. Officers back it; 38 neighbours objected.
Islington Council wants to turn the Tompion Community Hall on Percival Street into an office for its own parking team. The council’s Planning Committee decides the application on Thursday 12 November. Planning officers recommend approval.
The application, P2026/1577/FUL, comes from the council itself. That is why it goes to the full committee rather than being decided by an officer, the report says.
The hall covers 208 square metres on the ground floor of Mulberry Court, on the Percival Street estate in Bunhill ward. The Guinness Partnership owns the freehold. The council leases the space until 2034.
How the hall has been used
The officer report sets out the history:
- Until 2019: a community hall. A booking schedule from January 2017 shows activities every day except Sunday.
- 2019: closed for refurbishment. It has not been used as a community space since.
- 2021/22 to November 2024: used for a while as an office.
- Since November 2024: empty.
Its lawful use is still as a community space. That is why planning permission is needed now.
Why officers back the change
Islington’s Local Plan only lets community space go in limited cases. One is when a public body is rationalising its buildings. The council says this is such a case. Its Strategic Asset Management Plan aims for “a smaller but higher-quality network of community centres”.
The council’s assessment lists seven other community spaces within a 5 to 15 minute walk:
| Venue | Walk |
|---|---|
| Brunswick Estate Community Room | 5 minutes |
| Finsbury Unity Room, Michael Cliffe House | 5 minutes |
| St Luke’s Community Centre | 6 minutes |
| King Square Community Centre | 9 minutes |
| Gambier / Betty Brunker Hall | 10 minutes |
| Margery Street Community Hall | 12 minutes |
| Vibart Community Centre | 15 minutes |
Officers say several of those are bigger than Tompion. They conclude the loss is acceptable “on balance”.
The site is in the Central Activities Zone, where Islington’s plan makes offices the priority use. Up to 15 staff would use the office at any one time, possibly seven days a week, the council told planners. A condition would limit the space to office use only.
What objectors said
Letters went to 181 nearby addresses in July. When the report was written, 38 objections had come in from separate addresses. The chair of the Percival Estate Community also objected twice.
Their points include:
- the hall has not been offered for bookings since 2019, so a lack of bookings proves nothing about demand
- requests from residents to use the space were not met
- the nearby venues are not as good, and the space should be kept for the estate
- residents and the tenants’ association were not consulted before the application
- an office for the parking service does not outweigh losing the hall
- the council’s covering letter and assessment give different dates for when the hall was empty
On the dates, officers say they relied on those in the needs assessment, which the council clarified during the application. On consultation and future operators, the report says these “are matters to be addressed by the applicant”.
What it means for you
If you live on or near the Percival Street estate and used the hall before 2019, this is the decision that settles whether it comes back. The meeting starts at 7.30pm on 12 November. The agenda and papers are on the council’s committee site.
We will report the decision once it is published.
Have your say